IKE Home

  About IKE

  Priority Projects

  Publications

  Right to Know

  Contact Us

  Search IKE

Photo courtesy John Winters

Thanks to The Boren Foundation,
and Jack and Karen Kay Leonard
for making this website possible. 

 

Follow us on:

 

Major Initiatives:

Inept But At Your Service: Can You Trust Your Local Hardware Store?

Main Report

Quality of Advice Regarding Environmental Hazards

by Five Primary Hardware Store Chains Serving Indianapolis 

Store

Totals

Ace

Do-It-Best

Menards

Lowes

Home Depot

Number of Stores in Central Indiana    

48

12

11

8

10

7

Number of Stores in Indianapolis

30

10

6[1]

4

6

4

Number Visited At Least Once

39

10

6

8

9

6

Number in Areas With Older Housing

10

7

2

0

1

0

Lead-Based Paint and Lead Hazards

Score

 

 

 

 

 

EPA Protect Your Family Pamphlet Available

46%

3 of 10

0 of 6

1 of 8

9 of 9

5 of 6

LeadCheck® Swabs or Equivalent Available

44%

2 of 10

0 of 6

5 of 8

7 of 9

3 of 6

Gave Acceptable[2] Initial Advice

20%

2 of 8[3]

1 of 5

3 of 11

1 of 12

2 of 9[4]

Gave Acceptable Advice When Asked About Lead

47%

4 of 6

1 of 4

3 of 8[5]

5 of 9

2 of 5

Pesticide Advice

Score

 

 

 

 

 

Warning Signs Posted[6]

10%

0 of 10

0 of 6

0 of 8

2 of 9

2 of 6

Legally Gave Selection Advice[7]

5%

0 of 7

0 of 4

0 of 9

1 of 9[8]

1 of 8[9]

Gave Good Advice Safest for Kids[10]

26%

3 of 7

3 of 4

1 of 9

0 of 8[11]

2 of 7



[1] Three of the “Do It Best” stores on the website could not be found and one was not retail.

[2] Acceptable advice means advice that would not result in a contractor violating Indiana law that prohibits dry sanding, dry scraping, or burning of paint in a home built before 1960.  See IC 13-17-14 and 326 IAC 23-5-1.  U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development also essentially prohibits these practices on projects it funds.  See 24 CFR 35.140.  This is a very low threshold for acceptability that falls far short of lead-safe work practices.  Following acceptable advice can still result in a lead poisoned child and adult.

[3] One clerk gave excellent advice but the store did not have the EPA pamphlet or LeadCheck swabs.

[4] One clerk gave excellent advice.

[5] One clerk advised to used a chemical stripper but switched to sandpaper when asked about lead.

[6] Required to be posted if pesticide selection and use advice is given.  Indiana State Chemist has provided specific language in guidance.  See 357 IAC 1-9.

[7] Warning sign must be posted if pesticide selection and use advice is given.  See 357 IAC 1-9.

[8] One clerk advised that it was illegal for him to give advice and he did not give advice.

[9] One clerk advised that it was illegal for him to give advice and he did not give advice.

[10] "Good advice safest for kids" means advice that recommends use of gel and enclosed baits or acknowledges limitations of sprays or foggers.

[11] Pesticide warning sign posted but advised spraying and fogging as best option.